Do Hidden Cameras Cross A Line When Installed In Your Home?
Considering the legalities and ethics of in-home hidden recording devices
There are plenty of great reasons to have a hidden camera in your home. But to keep from crossing any legal or ethical lines, you need to consider how the footage will be used, where the cameras will be placed and why the cameras are in place to begin with. Once these issues are addressed, the use of covert cameras in the home can certainly be a smart move for safety, security and peace of mind.
Reasons to Use a Covert Camera in the Home
The first way to determine whether a covert camera makes sense in your home is to think about what the reason is behind the installation. For some homeowners, the main reason to install a hidden camera is to be able to identify a burglar in the event of a home break-in. For others, there is a security issue, restraining order or another circumstance that makes them feel unsafe in their own home.
You might also be interested in a nanny cam, which can be placed where children are taken care of by a nanny or babysitter. Nanny cameras are some of the most popular hidden cameras because they can give parents peace of mind about the wellbeing of their children while they are at work or even traveling. Similarly, a hidden camera might be used in the home as a way to ensure that elderly parents or grandparents are getting the care they deserve. Sadly, senior negligence is something that society needs to worry about.
Finally, a hidden cam can be used to ensure that cleaning staff or other in-home employees are not engaging in any illegal behavior or even stealing while they work in your residence.
Legality of Residential Hidden Camera Use
Another issue that many homeowners want clarification on is the legality of installing covert cameras within the home. While the specific laws pertaining to this issue can vary from state to state, it is widely accepted that filming within the home is completely legal. However, there are exceptions to this statement, and they include recording in places where people can reasonably expect to have privacy as well as recording audio, which is not such a clear-cut issue. However, anyone wanting to protect their homes or their families with a covert camera should have no concerns about its legality. Click here to read more about hidden camera laws.
Reasonable Expectation of Privacy
There are some places within a home where people are lawfully obligated to have a reasonable expectation of privacy. These might include bathrooms or private bedrooms, especially if there are guests or live-in staff residing within the home. Placing a hidden camera in the kitchen, living room or dining room are all generally accepted practices, but placing one in the bathroom is considered ethically and sometimes legally inappropriate. If employees like a nanny or cleaner live in the home, and have their own private bedroom, placing a hidden camera in their personal space may also be crossing a line and perhaps even violating their right to privacy.
Audio Recording Caveats
Audio recording is a completely different issue than video recording. When investing in a covert camera, you should almost always pick one that does not include an audio recording function. In most states, it is illegal to record a person's conversation without their consent, and doing so can result in legal action. Even in states with more relaxed views on audio recording, taping a conversation is not allowed unless at least one party involved gives consent. To be safe, it is best to avoid any audio recordings and stick instead to covert cameras that only record video footage.
To sum up: When deciding whether a hidden camera is the right choice for you, be sure to give thought to the location, whether the room gives people a reasonable expectation of privacy, whether there is any audio recording involved and what the overall objective of the camera is. If you are concerned with your home's security or you want to get peace of mind about the people you hire to clean or repair your home, babysit your children or care for your elderly relatives, a hidden camera can be an ideal investment.
Published July 17th, 2021